A rubric is an assessment tool that lists the criteria for a piece of work, or what counts and gradations of quality for each criterion, from excellent to poor. Students read different versions of the cinderella fairy tale. Title characters setting problem solution what makes this version of cinderella different. Writing process rubric for short fictional narrative 80 points. Remember how in the disney version, cinderella gets a bunch of chill birds to help her make a dress. Additionally, this rubric will help teachers assess this. As a whole group, explain to the students that they will be comparing and contrasting two versions of the story cinderella. Cultural cinderella story rubric and guidelines by mae ulrich. To compare larger documents or excel spreadsheets content, try draftable desktop. Students then write an essay comparing and contrasting the two versions of cinderella. They will also compare and contrast two or more versions of the. It includes space to compare contrast cinderella and two other versions.
This chart is to be used when comparing several different versions of cinderella across cultures usas disney version, the german aschenputtel version, the chinese yeh shen version, and an additional version of your choosing. Comparing and contrasting different versions of a story sas. Genre study of the cinderella story teachers network. Tell us which story you enjoy and why titles of cinderella around the world. In this class, online discussions will count towards your assignments grade in the course see syllabus. This cute book is absolutely packed with australian slang and cultural references. If you have a favorite cinderella around the world story, leave us a note in the comments. Then, a discussion about the w want to know follows. Choose two characters one good and one bad to compare using the fairy tale lessons sheet. This barnyard version of the cinderella story features a mildmannered chicken, a fashionconscious fairy goosemother, and a prince at a fowl ball.
My document is too long or too large the file size limits for our online compare tool are 300 pages and 10 mb. Find versions of the cinderella tale from as many cultures as you can. These rubrics can also be used to communicate students language expectations to both families and students. While creating rubrics can be time consuming, it is often a worthwhile investment.
This is a brothers grimm cinderella to disney cinderella comparison. Materials therubricbelowisbuiltaroundthefollowinginitialideas. Developing rubrics abet 2010 webinar series handout. I decided to teach this using the three little pigs. Movie adaptation dvd cover and booklet project rubric.
The plans are designed to compare cinderella grimms. Offers few opinions and makes no personal connections to the text. Korean cinderella comparecontrast printable pdf, free compare. Postit notes are utilized throughout the lesson sequence. Then, ask students to think of things they want to know more about regarding the story of cinderella. They are lazy and they make cinderella clean the house. Use what many think to be the original version of cinderella the ancient egyptian version, and the cinderella we all know and love today to help your students work on an important comprehension skill comparing and contrasting. Students are to read several versions of cinderella from a variety of cultures and choose two stories to compare and contrast. Did they look the way you thought they were going to in the movie. The disney version allows cinderella to have a room in the top of the house so they are a little kinder than the original family but the grimms version allows her to have no bed. Even though they cant help it, they are still enamored with cinderella and forget to fill in some of their. Introducing different versions of cinderella share my lesson.
Contrast chart pdf for each student for each cinderella storybook. Reading street common core supplement for first grade cinderella unit 4. Easy auch an outofwork princess applies to become the bride of prince drupert, but first she must pass several tests, including a cooking contest. A lot of the fairy tale stories that we have seen as young adults and even as adults are original folk tale stories that have been modified and rewritten to accommodate our new cultures.
Aesops fables two versions of each story to compare and contrast. Introducing different versions of cinderella lesson plan template and teaching resources. Students will write their version of a cinderella story using literary elements and their culture. This free product includes typed versions of both stories, vocabula. Cinderella stories assessment comparing and contrasting different versions of a story.
Read yehshen by ailing louie and compare and contrast the fairy tale elements of the chinese tale to the 1812 grimm version. I chose cinderella by ruth sanderson i help students fill in their chart. The rubric will help guide students along, as well as a checklistnotes about literary elements. Brothers grimm cinderella to disney cinderella comparison. Reading different versions of cinderella can be so much fun. Comparing the stories next, draw a venn diagram on a board or chart. Swbat compare this version of cinderella with previous versions they are familiar with and analyze differing points of view. Strategylesson suggestions assessment for learning suggestions venn diagram with web 2. After the passing of her mother, cinderella is no longer welcome as a family member to the father or the household.
Enjoy the genre of folk tales and fables while encouraging retelling of characters, setting, and events from two different versions of this classic story. A cinderella story grade 2 summary 2nd grade students will be integrating social studies cultural awareness with cultural stories of cinderella. Debbie haren sherry climo the princess and the golden shoes egyptian cinderella father remarried and new queen was mean towards the princess rhodopis is the girls name kidnapped by pirates made friends with the sheep in a meadow who later help her made a servant by the other. Offers few opinions and makes limited connections to the text. What evidence does the author give to show it is a type of cinderella story. Rubrics can be attached to gradable items, which include assignments, essay and short answer test questions, blogs, journals, wikis, and discussion board forums and threads. They may lead to a grade or be part of the grading process but they are more specific, detailed, and disaggregated than a grade. A comparison of the two forms of the roman rite mass structures orientation language the purpose of this presentation is to prepare you for what will very likely be your first traditional latin mass tlm. I hand out the comparing chart and pull out the book that is most like the disney version of cinderella that most of my students are familiar with and read it. Guidelines and rubric for online discussion boards. Compare and contrast the korean cinderella story with the. The cinderella story lesson plans and teaching ideas behind the scenes with cinderella in this unit plan students compare the classic tale with a version set in the pre civil war south, moss gown by william hooks, noting the architecture, weather, time period, and culture as depicted in the text and illustrations.
Lessons and activities that help kids explore story elements, appreciate different cultures, and compare 10 versions of this timeless fairy tale. In order to evaluate how cultural values are reflected in literature, you will read and compare two versions of cinderella with the american disney version. For prereading ideas and background information on folktales and their conventions, see around the world in 80 books. In this classroom clip, albuquerque teacher clara gonzalesespinoza introduces a character study of cinderella by sharing a number of diverse versions of the cinderella story, chosen to reflect the. Compare and contrast different versions of cinderella by. When her wish is granted, cinderella finds herself at the ball, and the prince finds himself in love, but cinderella disappears at the stroke of midnight. Older students might make notes of some of those commonalities as you read. Comparing different versions of the same story worksheets. Stories must include elements of the cinderella myth free rubric builder and assessment tools. Below is an example of a rubric that you might want to use. Ask students to tell you about the disney version of cinderella.
Comparing two stories template to use comparing the three snow bears by jan brett and goldilocks and the three bears. Teaching with cinderella stories from around the world. Cinderella stories from around the world utah education network. Cinderella is the delightful retelling of the classic fairy tale of a beautiful young maiden who is at the mercy of her cruel stepmother and stepsisters. Write a paragraph or two that describes the similarities and differences that you have found between your version and your partners version of the story. As an important literary technique,differences in perspective and point of view are exemplified in stories with the same central theme, such as this korean version of cinderella plan your 60minute lesson in english language arts or literature with helpful tips from dr. Had their mothers temper, less beautiful than cinderella. Students read one or more other versions of the cinderella story and compare them using a venn diagram. The first known telling of the cinderella story is thought to be in china. How to create and use rubrics for formative assessment and. Rubrics as students discuss, write, and deliver presentations, use the following gradelevel rubrics to guide your observations of language proficiency.
Ask students to look for things that the story of cinderella has in common with the roughface girl. This makes a great little booklet to compare and contrast characteristics of different versions of cinderella. Several version of cinderella are read to students as they fill out. In order to evaluate how cultural values are reflected in. For more information, visit read and listen to the story of cinderella. How to create and use rubrics for formative assessment and grading book. As a class, evaluate the class paragraph using the attached rubric. Students will read the chinese version of cinderella, called yehshen. Students read two cinderella stories from two different cultures. Students will compare cinderella to other versions of the same tale from around the world. Unit rationale fairy tales are a part of our culture. Includes teacher information, student directions, and grading rubric.
Comparing and contrasting with the three little pigs the. Students fill in how the version begins, good character, evil charac. It has appeared in the folklore of many cultures, with over 500 versions alone in europe. I tell the students that today we are going to listen to a cinderella story and then choose a book to read with a small group. What story has wicked stepsisters, a fairy godmother, glass slippers, and a girl who works hard and ends up marrying a prince. What a fun way to compare two versions of the same story this 22 page unit offers vocabulary, reading comprehension strategies, creative writing, poetry, art, and math. The culminating task for the unit to utilize a venn diagram to compare and contrast two previouslyread cinderella stories of their own choosing. This lesson will address literature standards by demonstrating their reading and comprehension skills through comparing and contrasting different interpretations of the same story. After reading different versions of cinderella, use fairy tales around the world to compare the different cinderella stories.
Most of us already have mental rubrics so this is an opportunity to formalize and document those ideas. The cinderella story is told in many different ways by people from many different cultures. The cinderella story lesson plans and teaching ideas. It provides you with an opportunity to reflect on the purpose of the assignment and your expectations.
Literature circle assessment rubric level one level two level three level four discussion does not participate in group discussions. Students simply color the picture by following a code. Once upon a time in this lesson, students will compare and contrast. In this lesson, students will compare and contrast two versions of a fairy tale. The original versions of classic fairy tales are actually horrifying photos. This lesson on comparing and contrasting stories will focus on finding similarities and differences in versions of stories that are by different authors from. Grading rubrics rubrics give the instructor the opportunity to set specific evaluation criteria for an assignment which conveys their expectations to the student in advance of grading and helps ensure a more consistent assignment of grades to all students. Explain that there are many versions of cinderella from many different cultures and over the next few days you are going to be reading and comparing the stories. They will read another version and identify similarities and differences of.
For all of you who love the fairy godmother, dont get your hopes up for the fairytale. Pearson supplement, reading street supplement, spelling words, color by word. Scoring rubric submission section evidence score institutional demographic information identification of an award category facultyled team institutionwide project overview 40 total points project description unscored section project title succinct 30 words or less. Throughout history different versions of cinderella have been created. Cinderella tab book comparing different versions of a popular fairy tale. The rubrics feature of blackboard can help you grade assignments quickly while at the same time providing concrete, detailed feedback to students. This rubric is a great tool to show students what is expected of them in a concrete way. For todays lesson you will need either the smartboard cinderella compare and contrast lesson. When assigning a compare and contrast writing assignment, students need to be aware of what makes an outstanding written work. I made a little packet similar to my other reading comprehension packets for my littles to learn how to. Comparing and contrasting is a higher level thinking skill promoted in the common core standards leading to the ability to comprehend and analyze texts through various topics and genre. Compare and contrast two versions of the same story. Below is an example of a rubric that you might want to use when assessing student work. Creating and using rubric bergen community college.
So i pull out all of my cinderella books id had the librarian gather for me. P a this activity is designed to be used in conjunction with a performance of ipa productions cinderella. Sfusd common core state standards based report card for english language arts rubrics fifth grade reading standards for literature rl. The role of rubrics in advancing and assessing student. Cinderella is arguably the most familiar and beloved fairy tale the world has ever known. This is officially named the extraordinary form of the roman rite. Read a traditional fairy tale such as red riding hood or other tale that has many different cultural perspectives. Compare and contrast the korean cinderella story with the american version pdf free 2016 carolyn wilhelm, wise owl factory printable created by. They will then choose another cinderella story from a culture of their choice to compare to the walt disney version and yehshen. Comparecontrast, literature fourth grade language arts. Students will listen to the charles perrault version of cinderella and identify the main characters, plot and conflict.
The original versions of classic fairy tales are actually. A multicultural guide the story known as cinderella has more known variants than any other folktale. Compare and contrast versions of a story what story has wicked stepsisters, a fairy godmother, glass slippers, and a girl who works hard and ends up marrying a prince. Comparing cinderella and the roughface girl education world. Cinderella lives in a house with her two sisters barbarella and annabella. The first page is an example rubric and the second page is a blank rubric template for your use. Comparing two stories use a venn diagram to compare two stories the fairy tale cinderella and the native american cinderella story, the roughface girl. Compare and contrast two or more versions of the same story e. I have six different versions because i have six groups of students and i show them. I believe that comparing these two versions of the cinderella story has lead to. Cinderella stories beacon learning center lesson plans. Use the cinderella chart below to help you organize your information. Inform the class that they will be reading versions of cinderella.
Add the culture represented in each story read to the class comparing. Comparison of 2 versions of cinderella essay, research paper cinderella is the tale of a young woman who dreams to have a better life because she is treated like a. Comparing the texts will allow students to learn about intertextuality the relationships between texts as well. If necessary, use a disney version picture book and do a picture walk to go over some of the details. Compare and contrast versions of a story macmillanmcgrawhill. Ask the students to help develop the main plot of the cinderella story that they are most familiar with. District site literacy implementation rubric this rubric was developed to assist teachers and administrators in effectively implementing a researchbased englishlanguage arts instructional program. Student groups reach consensus on understandings through oral discussions. It can easily be reused with different versions of the cinderella story. Disney has brought cinderella, sleeping beauty, and other fairy tale. The story of cinderella guidelines and rubric one of the bestknown fairy tales in the world is cinderella. They analyze the differences between the two versions by citing specific adaptations in the film version, indicating the effect of each adaptation on the story, and deciding if they felt the change had a positive effect on the overall story. This is a detailed oral presentation rubric 100 pt.
However, cinderella, in spite of her mean apparel, was a hundred times more handsome than her sisters, though they were always richly dressed. What can we learn from fairy tales as middle school students. Compare in the land of small dragon with cinderella like tales from other cultures, such as china, egypt, germany, and native american groups. These rubrics attempt to describe how students develop and demonstrate the skills. Students explore versions of the cinderella tale from various cultures around the world. This story made its way across oceans taking on the colors, clothes, and traditions of many different cultures. Reading and comparing several versions of traditional tales can be a way of developing critical thinking. Compare and contrast the fable the boy who cried wolf with a modern version, betsy who cried wolf by gail carson levine. They are introduced to a new version of cinderella called cinderelly. Scoring rubric for grant proposal exemplary adequate 3 pts 2 pts needs improvement 1 pt missing 0 pts score project description provides a clear explanation. It is also to be used when comparing hans christian andersens the litt.
244 1037 1247 792 304 501 1100 819 1405 1037 862 1031 303 850 1422 1032 645 769 871 1124 1211 545 503 856 1364 1424 262 4 596 141